Is The Song of Achilles Worth Reading?
Ada’s Score
Miller retells the Iliad not as epic but as elegy — and that shift changes everything. The novel centers Patroclus, history's footnote, giving him interiority, longing, and a love story that Homer only implies. The prose is luminous without being ornate, and Miller earns her emotional crescendos honestly. What makes it devastating is structural: we know the ending from the first page, so every tender moment carries grief inside it. The tragedy isn't a surprise — it's the entire architecture. This book rewards those drawn to myth reimagined through queer longing, beauty, and irreversible loss.
Deep Dive“Miller made me weep for men dead three thousand years. This is what mythology was always meant to feel like—personal and eternal.”
An Ancient Love Story That Shatters Modern Hearts
There are books that break you quietly, and this is one of them — Miller writes Patroclus with such tender interiority that by the time the tragedy arrives, it feels less like myth and more like personal loss. The prose has this luminous, almost aching quality, as if every sentence knows where the story is going and is trying to slow down. I finished it in a kind of grief I didn't expect, and I've never quite shaken it.
Ada Brief
AI reading intelligence“Miller made me weep for men dead three thousand years. This is what mythology was always meant to feel like—personal and eternal.”
An Ancient Love Story That Shatters Modern Hearts
There are books that break you quietly, and this is one of them — Miller writes Patroclus with such tender interiority that by the time the tragedy arrives, it feels less like myth and more like personal loss. The prose has this luminous, almost aching quality, as if every sentence knows where the story is going and is trying to slow down. I finished it in a kind of grief I didn't expect, and I've never quite shaken it.
Ada’s reservations
Miller's prose is gorgeous, but Patroclus narrates his own life as a passive worshipper of Achilles. The romance soars; the back-half war drags, leaning on Iliad nostalgia to do its emotional lifting.
Ada’s score reflects both strengths and reservations.
Book Details
- Publisher
- Avon
- Published
- January 1, 2021
- Pages
- 480
- Language
- English
Get This Book
Affiliate linksISBN: 9780062060631
Disclosure: ReadAda earns a commission on purchases made through these links, at no extra cost to you.
Ada’s Score
4.36
Ada’s editorial score — not an aggregate of reader reviews.
Common Questions About The Song of Achilles
- Is The Song of Achilles worth reading?
- Miller made me weep for men dead three thousand years. This is what mythology was always meant to feel like—personal and eternal. Ada rates it 4.4 out of 5.
- What are the main weaknesses of The Song of Achilles?
- Miller's prose is gorgeous, but Patroclus narrates his own life as a passive worshipper of Achilles. The romance soars; the back-half war drags, leaning on Iliad nostalgia to do its emotional lifting.
- How many pages is The Song of Achilles?
- The Song of Achilles is 480 pages long — around 8–9 hours at an average reading pace.
