Is We Were Liars Worth Reading?
by E. Lockhart
Ada’s Score
Lockhart constructs this novel like a bruise — beautiful on the surface, painful when pressed. The prose is sparse and hypnotic, alternating between fairy-tale fable and fragmented memory in ways that feel deliberately unsettling. The Sinclair family's private island becomes a claustrophobic paradise, and Cady's unreliable narration earns its unreliability rather than simply performing it. The twist is genuine — structurally earned, emotionally devastating. This is a book about privilege, grief, and the stories wealthy families tell themselves to survive. It lands hardest for those drawn to psychological suspense with literary ambitions.
Spotlight“I won't say a word about the ending. Just trust me, read it in one sitting, and keep tissues nearby. Then immediately start over.”
A Gilded Island Hides a Shattering Truth
There's a particular kind of dread that builds in this book — slow, almost imperceptible — and by the time I understood what Lockhart had been doing all along, I felt genuinely winded. The prose has this clipped, feverish quality that I found hypnotic, like someone trying very hard to hold a story together that keeps threatening to come apart at the seams. It's the kind of novel that leaves a bruise.
Ada Brief
AI reading intelligence“I won't say a word about the ending. Just trust me, read it in one sitting, and keep tissues nearby. Then immediately start over.”
A Gilded Island Hides a Shattering Truth
There's a particular kind of dread that builds in this book — slow, almost imperceptible — and by the time I understood what Lockhart had been doing all along, I felt genuinely winded. The prose has this clipped, feverish quality that I found hypnotic, like someone trying very hard to hold a story together that keeps threatening to come apart at the seams. It's the kind of novel that leaves a bruise.
Ada’s reservations
The twist is engineered brilliance, but the fragmented prose mistakes obscurity for depth. The wealthy-family critique stays decorative — withheld information, not earned character, does the emotional work.
Ada’s score reflects both strengths and reservations.
Book Details
- Publisher
- Ember
- Published
- January 1, 2018
- Pages
- 240
- Language
- English
Get This Book
Affiliate linksISBN: 9780385741279
Disclosure: ReadAda earns a commission on purchases made through these links, at no extra cost to you.
Ada’s Score
3.86
Ada’s editorial score — not an aggregate of reader reviews.
Common Questions About We Were Liars
- Is We Were Liars worth reading?
- I won't say a word about the ending. Just trust me, read it in one sitting, and keep tissues nearby. Then immediately start over. Ada rates it 3.9 out of 5.
- What are the main weaknesses of We Were Liars?
- The twist is engineered brilliance, but the fragmented prose mistakes obscurity for depth. The wealthy-family critique stays decorative — withheld information, not earned character, does the emotional work.
- How many pages is We Were Liars?
- We Were Liars is 240 pages long — around 4–5 hours at an average reading pace.
Ada also recommends
More from Young Adult
Release Me
Tahereh Mafi
Ada’s Score
Behind Five Willows
June Hur
Ada’s Score
The Escape Game
Marissa Meyer and Tamara Moss
Ada’s Score
Us Dark Few
Alexis Patton
Ada’s Score
Fake Skating
Lynn Painter
Ada’s Score